Treadmill Versus Road Running: Mamamarathoner’s Observations

I’ve been doing a lot of treadmill training this summer. In the beginning, I dreaded it. Apparently I’m not the only one, because many runners I ask call it the Dreadmill, after emitting a huge sigh.

The idea of running like a hamster in a wheel drove me crazy. I woke up and instead of thinking Yes! I get to run today! I thought Oh shit, not another trip to the gym to run on the mill.

My gym offers three treadmills with televisions, so best case scenario was getting there early enough to score one of those mills so I could watch some trashy talk show, like Jerry Springer (yes, I did) or Jersey Shore (uh huh, I tuned in). Worse case: TVs were taken and I was stuck watching whatever news show happened to be on one of the other four TVs.

I went a few times. I found it wasn’t so bad. And then, to my surprise, I began to actually enjoy the mill.

I found the mill was a bit more delicate on my legs. I have issues with my hamstrings regardless of how much I roll, massage, and stretch. The mill seems to be a bit more forgiving with each stride.

Also, I worked harder on the mill. I don’t know why, but for some reason staring down at the pace I was running kept me wanting to run faster. I have a Garmin. I can stare down at it when I want. But on the mill, I don’t want to see myself running slower than a 6.3, so I set it there and force myself to go faster, harder, for longer. And over time, my pace has improved.

This weekend while on vacation I had a chance to run outside for the first time in several weeks. I did two miles outside, then headed into the fitness room where we were staying and ran another few. I finished up outside with a few more miles, and then I contemplated the difference between the two runs.

On the road, I ran more leisurely. Enjoyed the scenery. Took it easier on my body. Found myself not caring so much about my pace.

On the mill, I jacked up the speed. Couldn’t go lower than 6.3. Had to hit the incline button a few times. Had to push it harder.

On the road, I really felt each footstep’s impact, each strike, each jar of the pavement. The pavement felt hard beneath my feet.

On the mill, I felt the give in the belt as it turned. It was an easier, softer run, at least when it came to the pounding my feet were taken.

Outside, I felt a faster pace was more difficult than it was on the mill. I am guessing this is due to the forward motion of the belt on the mill versus the nonmovement on the pavement. Outside, I had to really push to go faster, to hold a faster pace.

Inside, I got bored.

Outside, I didn’t.

I believe the key to my future running plans is to continue to use both in training.

I feel the treadmill can probably make me a stronger, faster runner, because I want to perform harder when stationary.

Outside, I see the beauty in running. Hear my footfalls, listen to the birds, see the sunrise, and understand that running is not only an exercise but a way to meditate. A way to live.

They are two different runs, and I feel from now on I will need them both to improve and enjoy running.

Where do you run the most, and which do you prefer? And why?

Personal best 10K, 53 Minutes, 2nd Place, And Feeling Great!

So, I did it!

I PRed at 53 and change at today’s Dolphin Days Race on St. Simon’s Island!

I don’t know my splits because dummy me didn’t realize I could do that on my Garmin until just now – show my pace for each mile, argh!

But I do know my first mile was at 8:26 and my average was 8:31.

Can we say woo hoo (woo hoo)?

Let me hear you say woo hoo (woo hoo!)

This was the smallest run that I have ever participated in.

In fact, it was so small that right before someone shouted, “GO!” they said, “We are missing four people. We’ll wait until they get here before we start.”

I would say there were about 50 participants total. I really loved that about the race. Usually people are pushing and shoving and racing to get to the start, to the front, or you are tripping over the slower people who don’t realize you should start in the back if you aren’t going to go fast.

Today it was just about 50 people mingling around, commenting on the cold weather, waiting for someone to yell START! People knew each other; many run together in a running club that I’m going to look into. I used to fear running with others, but now that my speed has improved I think it may be kind of fun.

The start line was just 10K Start spray painted in blue on the side of the road! 

It was frigid cold but of course once we began I didn’t notice. My headphone batteries went out at mile 3, which I thought might be bad. I do better focusing at speed when I have pumping music going on in my ears, and I didn’t even get to hear the Proclaimers sing, ” I would walk 500 miles! ” before the batteries died.

But it turned out fine. Instead I focused on finding that pace that didn’t totally take my breath away but that made me breathe harder and feel some kind of burn. That on the edge pace. Then I would fall back a little, doing about 8:40 for a half mile, and then push to do 8:20 or less for a stint.

At one point one of the girls I rode with to the race passed me, and we ran elbow and elbow for about a mile before I pushed on during one of my sprints. She came in right behind me by a few seconds and took fourth in her age (the next age category is pretty damn fast!)

Overall woman came in at 46 minutes. 46 ! In awe.

So the pushing hard made me wonder this:

Why do they say that you should be able to hold a conversation while running, and that if you can’t hold one you are running too hard for your ability?

I considered this for a while on the run as my lungs somewhat burned. Seriously, if I were able to talk normally, or hold down any type of conversation, wouldn’t that mean I wasn’t putting as much into it as I could?

When I am running hard, I don’t feel I should be able to talk. I shouldn’t be hyperventilating, of course, or so out of breath I think I might have a heart attack (at least, not until that last half mile to the finish line!)

I suppose some people are better at fast running while talking. I don’t get into it. Maybe that’s the solo runner in me. I would prefer to hear nothing or my music than someone trying to talk to me during fast paces.

If they are talking to me, then I am feeling as though I have to respond, and that’s just not something I really care to do while pushing myself to go further and faster.

And I always think, “If you are talking you aren’t going fast enough.”

Anyhoo . . .

The run was gorgeous, past the marsh. I saw a blue heron right beside us in the marsh and quite a few other birds. There were very few spectators and three drink stands serving water, but it was so cold I could barely drink. Two girls stood on the side of the road bundled up. One saw me coming and yelled, “Are you my mommy?”

I focused on the race during the run, my speed, my heart rate, and the girl wearing black and pink in front of me. I knew when we got close to the finish line I wanted to pass her. That was my goal.

I also had a silver haired guy in front of me for a while that I wanted to keep in sight. He had an easy stride, I would say he was doing about 8:20, so for me it was a little faster than I go but definitely someone on whom I could focus. He came in a minute ahead of me I’d say.

Afterwards the two girls I were running went on to do another 5, as they are training for a marathon. I did two more, but quite honestly I had run so hard for the race that I wasn’t into it and thought it would be a bad idea on my knee. So I ran about 1.75, then hung around and cheered on the kids that were doing the mile fun run (some of them in 6:20!)

I took second place in my age division; first was a minute faster at 52 something. We didn’t stay around for the award ceremony because they still had to do the 5K and we were ready to go by that point. I hear I may get a medal in the mail though – now ain’t that something for someone who started off after baby 2 running 10:30 miles?

My second speed accomplishment in racing was last year’s 5K at 8:20 miles. I am stoked I was able to go only ten seconds slower for an entire six miles during this race, which really proves the work I have been doing on speed has helped.

This makes me wonder how much faster I can go in the future. Can I hit 8 even? What about 7s? Right now it doesn’t seem possible, but if you had told me a few years ago that I’d be in the 8:30 range I would have laughed, rolled my eyes, and said, ” Only in your dreams!”

Hope all of your runs are good runs today!

Speedwork-It’s Worked!

I’ve never been a super fast runner. My girlfriend does a marathon in 3:15, and I love her for it but I’ll see 3:15 in my dreams (only, most likely!) I’d like to go faster, though, so during this marathon training I started working on speed. I’m happy to say that it has paid off! I did my last 5K at an 8:20 pace and I was able to keep up a 9:15-9:20 pace for the start of the past marathon. Had my knee not given out I would have finished the race around 4:20, and that includes stopping for pictures and potty breaks, so I would have been completely happy with that.

I noticed notable improvement (thanks to my can’t-live-without Garmin!) during training and actually in the first part of the marathon as well, before the old knee decided to stop.

This morning I went on a four mile run, my first four miler since the marathon, and I’m happy to report the knee feels good! I came back and immediately rolled it, iced it and stretched it. I’m hoping to do three tomorrow and then at least 5, if not 7, on Saturday, so I can resume mileage on the weekend. I was able to do the four miles at a 9:20 pace.

So, what worked in terms of speed? This is the plan that I followed.

I do four runs each week. I do one back to back (my days are Wed and Thurs but I hope to make it Sat and Sun so I can do a short run after a really long run and get used to the miles, which might help marathon performance).

Monday is a 5 miler. I do this one at a comfortable pace, pushing myself at least 15 seconds faster than feels comfortable for at least three of the miles and then dropping back just a bit for the last two.

Wednesday is a 4-5 miler. I do this one a little slower at the start and then finish the last mile to two 15 to 30 seconds faster. I found this helped a lot during training because those last two miles I’m more tired and it trained my body to work through that fatigue and go faster than felt completely comfortable. I could talk if I wanted, so I was not full out these miles, but I wouldn’t carry on a long conversation at this pace.

Thursday I generally do a shorter sprint run followed by biking. I started this when I was training for a tri, and I think I will continue since I want to start tri training in the summer for the fall season. I would do a 2-3 mile run all out, as fast as I could go for as long as I could go. This was my plan: Run fast.

Saturday is my long run. I do anywhere from 10-20 miles and I do this at a slower pace, incorporating at least 15-30 seconds faster than normal/slower pace throughout the run.

Drills work well. I end my Wednesday run and spend at least half a mile to a mile doing all out drills, trying to get down into the 5 minute mile pace. A month or so before the marathon I stopped doing drills for fear of injury, but I will resume these again next week if the knee holds up.

If you have some tips for speed, please leave them!